Home > Books > Understanding Health Policy: A Clinical Approach, 6e >
Chapter 9. Mechanisms for Controlling Costs View
Chapter 9 Mechanisms for Controlling Costs: Introduction
In Chapter 8, we discussed the general relationship between costs and health outcomes and explored the tension between painful and painless approaches to cost containment. In this chapter, we examine specific methods for controlling costs. Our emphasis is on distinguishing among the different types of cost control mechanisms and understanding their intent and rationale. We briefly cite evidence about how these mechanisms may affect cost and health outcomes.
Financial transactions under private or public health insurance (see Chapter 2, Figures 2–2, 2–3, and 2–4) may be divided into two components: 1. Financing, the flow of dollars (premiums or taxes) from individuals and employers to the health insurance plan (private health insurance or government programs), and 2. Reimbursement, the flow of dollars from insurance plans to physicians, hospitals, and other providers.
Cost-control strategies can be divided into those that target the financing side versus those that impact the reimbursement side of the funding stream (Figure 9–1 and Table 9–1). FIGURE 9–1.
View Full Size
Download Slide (.ppt)
Cost-control mechanisms may be applied to both the financing and reimbursement components of health care spending under a system of health insurance.
Table 9–1. Categories of Cost Controls
Cost controls aimed at the financing of health insurance attempt to limit the flow of funds into health insurance plans, with the expectation that the plans will then be forced to modify the outflow of reimbursement. Financing controls come in two basic flavors—regulatory and competitive.
Regulatory Strategies Dieter Arbeiter, a carpenter in Berlin, Germany, is enrolled in one of his nation's health insurance plans, the “sick fund” operated by the Carpenter's Guild. Each month, Dieter pays 7.5% of his wages to the sick fund and his employer contributes an equal 7.5%. The German federal government regulates these payroll tax rates. When the government proposes raising the rate to 8.5%, Dieter and his coworkers march to the parliament building to protest the increase. The government backs down, and the rate remains at 7.5%. As a result, physician fees do not increase that year. In nations with tax-financed health insurance, government regulation of taxes serves as a control over public expenditures for health care. This regulatory control is most evident when certain tax funds are earmarked for health insurance, as in the case of the German health insurance plans (see Chapter 14) or Medicare Part A in the United States. Under these types of social insurance systems, an ... GET ACCESS TO THIS RESOURCE
Sign In Username or Email Password
Get Free Access Through Your Institution
Contact your institution's library to ask if they subscribe to McGraw-Hill Medical Products.
Forgot Username? Forgot Password? Sign in via OpenAthens
What is MyAccess?
Sign in via Shibboleth
Subscription Options Pay Per View Timed Access to all of AccessMedicine 24 Hour
AccessMedicine Full Site: One-Year Individual Subscription
Buy Now View All Subscription Options
AccessMedicine Books Library Updates Quick Reference QMDT Guidelines DDx Diagnostic Tests Clinical Prep 2 Minute Medicine® English-Spanish Dictionary Calculators Drugs
McGraw-Hill Medical Multimedia Videos by Category Videos by System Exploring Essential Radiology Patient Safety Modules Female Reproductive System Module Pharmacology Lectures Cases Case Files® Family Practice Board Review Fluid/Electrolyte and AcidBase Cases Microbiology Cases Sherris Medical Microbiology Cases Pathophysiology Cases Clinical Neuroanatomy Cases Resident Readiness®: Internal Medicine
Patient Ed About AccessMedicine Advisory Board Hospital Corner
Sites AccessAnesthesiology AccessCardiology AccessEmergency Medicine AccessHemOnc AccessMedicina AccessMedicine AccessNeurology AccessObGyn AccessPediatrics AccessPharmacy AccessPhysiotherapy AccessSurgery Case Files Collection Clinical Sports Medicine Collection F.A. Davis PT Collection HarrisonMedicina JAMAevidence Murtagh Collection OMMBID Pharmacotherapy Principles & Practice
Study Tools Review Questions Clerkship Topics Flashcards Play Showdown!
Copyright © McGraw-Hill Global Education Holdings, LLC. All rights reserved. Your IP address is 220.127.116.11 Loading [Contrib]/a11y/accessibility-menu.js .