Arithmetic And The Road Beyond - Outlook India

Loading...

Click Here!

MAG AZI NE S

MO NE Y

TRAV E LLE R

BUS I NE S S

ARCHI V E S

SEARCH

S UBS CRI P TI O N

LO G I N

THE MAGAZINE

NATIONAL INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS SPORT ART & ENTERTAINMENT BOOKS & CULTURE SOCIETY

THE LATEST ISSUE 16 MARCH 2015 BUSINESS OPINION

Arithmetic And The Road Beyond The Budget seeks to harmonise growth with macroeconomic stability N. K. S I NGH

CLICK IMAGE FOR CONTENTS



AJIT SOLANKI Mail

Print

AAA

Share

INCREASE TEXT SIZE

Any ex-post-analysis of the budget is of course inevitably predicated on our predilections. Not necessarily prejudice but clearly our preferences. In the pre-reform era before 1991, the budget was primarily an accounting statement of expenditure and revenues. In the post-reform era beginning 1991, it has increasingly become a policy instrument covering what Barack Obama would call the embodiment of our values. Liberalisation increases our global interdependence and policy-making through the budget has become the preferred option of successive governments. This year there were added expectations—a stable government, a decisive leadership and favourable external factors like soft oil and commodity prices.

ALSO IN THIS STORY ECONOMY: BUDGET OVERVIEW

School Of Hard Knocks The NDA’s high-growth Budget formula, in combination with reduced social spends, is one that India can ill afford at this juncture OPINION

Whose Bharat Is It? Social spend takes dive, gold-diamond industry gets boost... BUDGET OVERVIEW

Digging In The Wrong Grave Eco Survey upends notion that ‘Jayanthi green tax’ stifled private sector projects

Has the 2015 Budget met the heightened expectation threshold?

Advertisement opens in new window

Click Here!

OPINION

Banking On Tall Promises Low deficit ratio, high growth, more tax revenue could just be a dream

1 The arithmetic: notwithstanding the increased revenue compulsions arising from the Fourteenth Finance Commission devolutions, with pressures on social spending not abetting, the Budget adhered to the path of fiscal consolidation. This fiscal targeting of 4.1 per cent has been met but the terminal target of 3 per cent has been postponed for an additional year. Cyclically adjusted fiscal targets for higher growth is now acceptable to economic analysts even though fiscal prunists and rating agencies would wish otherwise.

BUDGET 2015: POLITICS

Pro-Poor? Bah! The budget factored affiliate outfits’ concerns, but still fell short INTERVIEW

‘We Should Not Be So Scared Of Foreign Investors’ An interview with two-time finance minister Yashwant Sinha who has left an indelible stamp on the Indian economy. OPINION

A Sharing Of Instruments RBI’s new brief to curb inflation comes with a cut in its independence OPINION

Goldie The Pig Takes Wings The FM’s new gold schemes are from an old, creaking vault

On the revenue side, the tax rates have been by and large kept stable. On the indirect tax side, the decisive change will come with the implementation of the GST. A credible time-frame has now been articulated, signalling its introduction from 2016. This will make India a large common economic market, eliminate cascading impact, enhance revenues and create growth multipliers. Given the enormous work involved, there is some scepticism on adherence to the time-frame. In the negotiating dynamics with states, some products have been kept out. We must accept that the best cannot become the enemy of the good. While no one has liked the increased service taxes, it would be necessary to align them with the GST.

PERSONAL FINANCE

The Rs 4.44 Lakh Deception Decoding the finance minister’s spiel on tax savings INTERVIEW

We Are Wasting Money In The Name Of Budgetary Allocation Social entrepreneur Vijay Mahajan on how the budget has not addressed the issue of implementation of social schemes and policies.

PHOTO

2 On the direct tax side, India’s corporate tax rates were high. It detracted new investments, domestic and foreign. Its reduction by 5 per cent over the next four years is positive, though the time path is opaque. Individual tax rates have remained unchanged and stable but some new cesses have been added for higher secondary education and could be imposed to support the Swachh Bharat initiative. Advertisement opens in new window

NEWS

BLOGS

LATEST

Man Kills 6 People In 2 Hours With Iron Rod In Palwal Pak PM Calls Emergency Meeting IMA Calls Off Doctors' Strike Bitcoins, Ethereum Illegal: Jaitley MORE>>

Click Here!

The real problem with direct taxes is its narrow base. Leaving out agriculture sector as a whole shrinks the tax base significantly. While farmers must be spared, untaxed profligate expenses by rich farmers or the use of agricultural income as tax shelters need fresh consideration. Till the tax base is skewed further, relief in the exemption threshold for the middle class would remain elusive. 3 On retrospective taxation, the budget has reiterated the commitment that it would be avoided in future. GAAR has been put in cold storage since on many issues like base erosion, profit sharing and treaty shopping, tax arbitrage consensus on best international practice is yet to emerge. 4 On the expenditure side, there was a dilemma. Analysts argued in favour of larger public outlays on infrastructure and the social sector. Others felt that fiscal consolidation was crucial for long-term growth. The budget has sought to harmonise the virtues of growth and job creation with macroeconomic stability. Apart from a decisive fillip to infrastructure, particularly railways and national highways, it has sought to protect spending on key social areas like the National Health Mission, child nutrition, mid-day meal and Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan, to mention a few. States have now complained that for centrally sponsored schemes the pattern of funding will undergo a change, casting an additional burden on their resources. There is also concern that several centrally sponsored schemes, like the Backward Region Grant Fund to support initiatives in Bihar following its bifurcation from Jharkhand, deployment in KBK districts of Orissa or in the Bundelkhand region, have been dropped. This is the centrepiece of the Fourteenth Finance Commission. While devolution from the divisible tax pool has increased from 32 per cent to 42 per cent, it has naturally resulted in dropping of several schemes from central outlays or changed the pattern of funding. States gain not so much from the additional resources but the flexibility they now have in conception, design and implementation of projects best suited to their local needs. This was a persistent demand of several chief ministers. In accepting this broad approach, the government has given a fillip to the concept of cooperative federalism. While speedy presidential address to state reform initiatives ushers in an equally competitive federalism. Advertisement opens in new window

MOST VIEWED

MOST COMMENTED

Game, Set, Winning Match Sorting The Ethnic Mess MORE>>>

Outlookindia 1,231,280 likes

Like Page

Contact Us

Be the first of your friends to like this

5 The Budget makes a substantial difference on the ease of doing business and improving investment climate. These initiatives are what may be called work-in-progress. They relate to an expert body on dispute resolution, special commercial divisions in various courts, a comprehensive bankruptcy code in consonance with global standards and a public contracts (resolution of disputes) bill to simplify resolution of disputes arising in the case of public contracts. Advertisement opens in new window

6 An

Click Here!

Apart from a fillip to infrastructure, it has sought to protect spending on key social areas like health, education and mid-day meals.

important budget initiative is to redefine the relationship between the Union finance ministry and the Reserve Bank of India. In the past there were repeated demands that given favourable macro parameters like fiscal consolidation, rationalisation of subsidies, subdued inflation and acceptable current account deficit, the interest rates should come down. There is uncertainty on the mandate of the Reserve Bank of India. This leads to uninformed criticism. For the first time, the RBI and the finance ministry concluded an agreement to keep the inflation target in the band of 2 per cent to 6 per cent, with the RBI being tasked to monitor and report. This will harmonise monetary and fiscal policy. Hopefully, the monetary policy committee will enable both Mint Street and North Block to work in tandem. 7 Harnessing India’s biggest idle asset—gold—through a monetising scheme and gold bonds will have multiplier benefits. This, however, needs imaginative marketing and amnesty for rural peasants who cannot readily explain the source of their acquisition. The scheme must be evolved with innovation and imagination to harness this asset. The government must use this opportunity and learn from other countries like Turkey, which have harnessed their gold more productively. 8 Notwithstanding the Click Here! resource constraint, there is an important fillip to highways and railways through innovative financing. In railways, special purpose vehicles will help garner non-budget resources through financial institutions, external flows and public-private partnership. Similarly, in the highways sector, securitisation of their future revenue stream from tolls along with tax-free bonds can garner market-related resources. Care must be taken so that projects are commercially viable. If borrowings are backed by guarantees, the additional contingent liability has fiscal consequences. Advertisement opens in new window

9 On employment and job creation, there have been several worthwhile initiatives; particularly, the proposal for setting up the Micro Units Development Refinance Agency (MUDRA) Bank with a corpus of Rs 20,000 crore, and an amount of Rs 3,000 crore for credit guarantees to small enterprises and manufacturing units (out of which 62 per cent are owned by the categories of SC/ST and OBCs). This will give a push to the large unorganised sector. jam (Jan Dhan-Aadhaar-Mobile) improves the quality and reach of subsidies and enhanced credit fosters rural entrepreneurship. 10 On agriculture, the emphasis has been on enhancing the reach of agricultural credit and laying the daunting targets of Rs 15,000 crore for the long term rural credit fund, Rs 45,000 crore for the short term cooperative rural credit refinance fund and Rs 15,000 crore for the short term regional rural banks refinance fund. Productivity enhancement through soil testing labs will improve the pattern of fertiliser use. Of course, the more difficult issues of agriculture would need to be separately addressed, including skill inculcation and providing nonagricultural employment through orderly urbanisation, smart cities

Advertisement opens in new window

and skill-based manufacturing hubs. The budget is a pragmatic balancing between conflicting objectives— between growth and macro stability; between industrialisation and social sector spending; between encouraging the corporate sector and protecting the poor. The initiatives and legislations remain daunting challenges. Continuing efforts to secure bipartisan support is critical in recognising that the ordinance route must be exceptional. As Mark Twain put it, “If it is a miracle, any sort of evidence will answer, but if it is a fact, proof is necessary.” For the budget, the proof of the pudding is always in the eating. (Former expenditure and revenue secretary N.K. Singh is now a member of the BJP) READ MORE IN: N.K. SINGH

MICROFINANCE SYSTEM

BUDGETS

BUSINESS

OPINION

POST A COMMENT

You are not logged in, To comment please Login / Register or use

DAILY MAIL (5)

4 D Ghai

"Why you did not blame Madam ji ??..."

I dont know whether to laugh or cry at your 'arguments'. The Hindu Taliban is in power. While madam is counting her money. Do you want Sonia to come back to power so that we can all blame her again? MAR 07, 2015 10:50 PM , , LIKE(1) DISLIKE(1) REPORT ABUSE

Doctors take a decade to produce, and that is why it requires VISIONARY leadersto give proper direction / budgetary allocation. The benefits of such policy only hurt in the short term and the benefits are seen only after a decade. That is why only good leaders will think of such things and it is a good litmus test.' Miso Baba Then how you blame Modi for not ensuring Indian Doctor : Patient Ratio equal to West in his nine year Rule ?? Why you did not blame Madam ji ?? MAR 07, 2015 05:04 PM ASHOK KUMAR GHAI, MUMBAI, INDIA LIKE(2) DISLIKE(0) REPORT ABUSE

Ghai , Doctors take a decade to produce, and that is why it requires VISIONARY leadersto give proper direction / budgetary allocation. The benefits of such policy only hurt in the short term and the benefits are seen only after a decade. That is why only good leaders will think of such things and it is a good litmus test. Modi, OTOH in nine months, could not have given birth even if he was impregnated, as he is not a woman, and we all know that! MAR 07, 2015 04:01 PM , , LIKE(2) DISLIKE(1) REPORT ABUSE

Load More

NEXT STORY : A SHARING OF INSTRUMENTS

DOWNLOAD THE OUTLOOK MAGAZINES APP. SIX MAGAZINES, WHEREVER YOU GO! PLAY STORE AND APP STORE RELATED

ECONOMY: BUDGET OVERVIEW

School Of Hard Knocks The NDA’s high-growth Budget formula, in combination with reduced social spends, is one that India can ill afford at this juncture

OPINION

Whose Bharat Is It? Social spend takes dive, golddiamond industry gets boost... REETIKA KHERA

BUDGET OVERVIEW

Digging In The Wrong Grave Eco Survey upends notion that ‘Jayanthi green tax’ stifled private sector projects PRAGYA SINGH

LOLA NAYAR , SHARAT PRADHAN , MINU ITTYIPE , PRACHI PINGLAY-PLUMBER

MORE FROM N.K. SINGH

OPINION

A Bihar Mirror, For An Indian Reflection Not caste, pro-development youth will be a factor in the Bihar vote

JUMP CUT

Necessary Birthing India needs a think tank to support its developmental aims. would the Niti Aayog meet this broad objective?

REVIEW

A Timely Expose A well documented account of the lapses in the hawala probe

Advertisement

ABOUT US CONTACT US SUBSCRIBE ADVERTISING RATES COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER COMMENTS POLICY OSM AWARDS NEWSSCROLL OUTLOOK TOPICS : A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

MAIN STORIES

MONEY

CURRENT ISSUE INVEST COVER STORY SPEND NATIONAL SAVE INTERNATIONAL EARN BUSINESS INSURE BOOK REVIEWS ASK DOCUMENTS ESSAYS EXTRACTS INTERVIEWS OPINIONS PORTRAITS PROFILES RAJESH RAMACHANDRAN

or just type initial letters

Search with Letters Go

BUSINESS

TRAVELLER

SOCIAL MEDIA

THE BIG STORY SPECIALS PERSPECTIVE PIXSTORY ENTERPRISE STRATEGY MARKETS C'EST LA VIE

TRAVELOGUES WEEKEND BREAKS HOLIDAYS WITH OT PHOTO FEATURES HOTELS

FACEBOOK TWITTER INSTAGRAM YOUTUBE RSS

Loading...

Arithmetic And The Road Beyond - Outlook India

Click Here! MAG AZI NE S MO NE Y TRAV E LLE R BUS I NE S S ARCHI V E S SEARCH S UBS CRI P TI O N LO G I N THE MAGAZINE NATIONAL INTERNATIONA...

531KB Sizes 2 Downloads 16 Views

Recommend Documents

An Outsider's Kashmir - Outlook Traveller - Outlook India
Nov 1, 2016 - This June, I planned my trip with a good load of guilt. ... I did realise after a while in Srinagar that c

Cash Outlook: India
Cash Outlook: India. IBGC Working Paper 13-01. Ruben Korenke, Nikhil Joseph and Benjamin D. Mazzotta. September 2013 ...

Indian entertainment and media outlook - PwC India
Apr 4, 2009 - Welcome to the 2009 edition of PricewaterhouseCoopers' Indian Entertainment and Media (E&M) Outlook, cover

Arithmetic of career - Tribune India
Nov 1, 2017 - Actuarial scientist: Actuarial science uses mathematics and statistics to assess risk. It applies in finan

?B.M. Munjal, Hero - Outlook India
Nov 2, 2015 - Hero's ?joint venture with Honda was running successfully and was ?en route to becoming the world's larges

Beyond Guernica and the Guggenheim Beyond Guernica and the
206_6_eng.pdf Last accessed May 23 2014. 23. Martin ...... thes, Michel Foucault, Pierre Francastel, and Umberto Eco, su

2015 health care outlook India - Deloitte
India. Estimated health care expenditure: $96.3 billion in 2013. Health care as a share of GDP: 5.0 percent in 20131. Sp

If You're Willing, She's Reddy - Outlook India
Jul 18, 2011 - Now, she's stepping back into Mumbai after 17 films in Telugu and Tamil, which include monster hits like

Revisiting India-Belgium Bilateral Relations | Diplomacy & Beyond
In fact, India's international trade volume has grown faster than GDP due to increasing exports of goods and services. T

ARITHMETIC
multiplication, division, recognizing equivalent fractions and mixed numbers, and estimating. • Operations with decima